Two days after the midterm election, Governor Gavin Newsom announced that he would commute the sentences of all 548 people currently awaiting execution on California's death row.[1] He described the decision in an open letter, saying he believes the death penalty is "incompatible with California's values."[2] This means that these prisoners would no longer face execution, but would instead serve out sentences of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Although this announcement has received considerable backlash, it is not particularly surprising coming from Newsom. After all, he imposed a moratorium on executions back in 2019, which is essentially a temporary suspension or pause on carrying out the death penalty. In fact, no prisoner has actually been executed in California since January 2006.[3] That's nearly 21 years without a single execution!
So, why the outrage from conservatives? How should we respond to this action by our Governor? Is this morally right, as Newsom is framing it to be? And perhaps the question that is most hotly debated, even among conservatives: is the death penalty itself justified? I'm breaking it all down for you today.
The Ideology Behind Newsom’s Decision
At first glance, this news seems shocking. Depending on which side of the ideological aisle you fall on when it comes to capital punishment, this is either a morally necessary measure or a total miscarriage of justice. That's because the death penalty is a weighty topic, and it should be handled with the gravity of life and death, because it quite literally involves the potential ending of someone's life.
But I wasn't surprised by Gavin Newsom's decision to commute these sentences. Was I surprised by the sheer volume? Absolutely. I didn't expect him to commute so many sentences all at once. But the underlying decision stems from ideological beliefs that he has been communicating throughout his tenure as Governor.
There were three main beliefs driving his decision, which he made clear in his open letter to Californians. These three arguments were:
1. The death penalty is morally wrong. He argues that the government should not take human life, even in response to horrific crimes.
2. The justice system is imperfect. He emphasizes the possibility of executing an innocent person and the unequal application of capital punishment.
3. The death penalty doesn't necessarily produce justice. He questions whether executions provide meaningful closure or healing for victims' families.[4]
These arguments are rooted in ideology – in your fundamental belief system about crime, government, and justice. And ultimately, the question we need to ask is whether that very ideology, that foundation on which these arguments are built, is sound or flawed.
Let's start with his first argument. Gavin Newsom argues that the death penalty is morally wrong, regardless of the crime committed. Underlying this position is a particular understanding of the purpose of punishment by the government: that punishment should primarily be about rehabilitation and preventing future harm. If you understand punishment primarily through that lens, then yes, the death penalty becomes unnecessary and potentially even counterproductive to that goal. After all, you cannot rehabilitate someone who has been executed.
But we must ask the question: Is that the primary purpose of our legal system? Is the goal of convicting and sentencing a criminal simply to rehabilitate them?
His second argument is that our justice system is imperfect, and therefore we cannot execute anyone because an innocent person might be wrongfully convicted. Now, I don't think anyone would argue that our justice system is incapable of making mistakes. It is made up of human beings, and human beings are fallible. But that raises a much bigger question: What should the response be to the potential for error? There is also the question of how we balance the possibility of wrongful convictions against the responsibility of the government to administer justice for those who have been murdered. The irreversible nature of the death penalty certainly makes this a serious concern, but what is the appropriate response to that concern?
His third argument is that executions don't necessarily provide meaningful closure or healing for victims' families, and therefore the death penalty doesn't necessarily produce justice. But here, I think we need to distinguish between justice and emotional closure. So, we must ask: What is justice? Is justice defined by what makes us feel better, what brings us comfort, or what our culture considers compassionate? Or is there an objective standard by which we should determine what justice requires?
I bring up these arguments to show you that Gavin Newsom's position makes sense when viewed through the lens of his worldview. If you believe the primary purpose of punishment is rehabilitation, that the possibility of human error makes certain punishments unacceptable, and that the state should never take a human life as punishment, then his decision follows logically from those beliefs. But that doesn't automatically make those beliefs true.
If your worldview isn't rooted in an objective, fundamental truth – if it's grounded primarily in your own opinions, what the culture tells you, or what feels most empathetic from your perspective – then you have to go back and examine the foundation itself.
The Power (and Abuse) of Clemency
But before we get into that, I want to examine the legal aspects of his decision for a moment. Everything I've discussed so far has to do with morality – did Gavin Newsom make the morally justified decision? But there's also a legal component to clemency, and regardless of where you fall ideologically on the death penalty, the legality of his actions still matters.
There is a huge difference between whether the Governor has the authority to do something, and whether exercising that authority in this particular way is good for our society. So, let's talk about what clemency is, what the California Constitution says about the Governor's authority, and whether Newsom is overstepping his role.
The Governor of California has the constitutional authority to grant clemency, which is a form of executive mercy that can take several forms. One form is a pardon. This is essentially forgiveness for an offense, providing certain legal relief from the consequences of a conviction. A second form is a commutation. This reduces or changes someone's criminal sentence without forgiving the crime or overturning the conviction. The third and final form is a reprieve. This temporarily delays the execution of a punishment or sentence. A reprieve doesn't change the sentence or forgive the crime; it simply delays carrying out the sentence itself.[5]
Newsom's proposed actions fall into bucket number two: commutation. He is not pardoning these prisoners or overturning their convictions. He is seeking to change their sentences from the death penalty to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Article V, Section 8 of the California Constitution gives the Governor the authority to grant reprieves, pardons, and commutations after conviction, subject to certain limitations.[6] So, yes, Newsom does have this constitutional authority.
But there is a caveat that's particularly relevant in this case. If someone has been convicted of a felony twice, the Governor cannot commute their sentence without a recommendation from the California Supreme Court, with at least four justices concurring.[7]
Of the 548 people Newsom intends to commute, 382 have more than one felony conviction.[8] This means that the California Supreme Court must provide its recommendation before Newsom can formally commute those 382 sentences. The Court isn't being asked to retry these cases or determine whether these individuals are guilty. Its constitutional role here is to provide a check against potential abuse of the Governor's clemency authority.
Now, here's where I think things get interesting. Clemency has traditionally been understood as an extraordinary form of relief, often granted after considering an individual's particular circumstances. It can serve as a safeguard in the justice system, allowing an executive to show mercy or correct an unjust or excessively harsh sentence, particularly when other avenues of relief have been exhausted.[9]
But is that really what Gavin Newsom is doing here? By proposing to commute every single death sentence in California, Newsom appears to be moving away from the traditional idea of individualized clemency and instead using his executive powers to accomplish a sweeping policy objective. In other words, he's using executive clemency to achieve something that resembles the practical effect of abolishing the existing death sentences in California, even though he is not technically abolishing capital punishment as a legal option.
Remember though that California voters have actually rejected attempts to abolish the death penalty multiple times! In 2012, voters rejected Proposition 34, which would have repealed the death penalty and replaced it with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. Then, in 2016, voters rejected Proposition 62, which would have done essentially the same thing. In that same election, voters actually APPROVED Proposition 66, which sought to speed up the death penalty process.[10]
The California District Attorneys Association put it excellently, saying, "Clemency is an extraordinary power intended to provide relief when the facts and circumstances of an individual case justify it. It was never intended to serve as a substitute for the legislative process."[11] Gavin Newsom personally opposes the death penalty and believes it should be abolished. But California voters have repeatedly declined to abolish it. So, while the Governor has constitutional authority to grant clemency, should that authority be used to accomplish a sweeping policy change that voters have previously rejected?
We need to distinguish between the existence of a constitutional power and the responsible exercise of that power. Just because the Governor has the authority to do something doesn't mean that every use of that authority is appropriate. In this case, when an elected official uses an extraordinary executive power to accomplish a broad policy objective, bypassing the ordinary democratic debate over that policy, we have legitimate reasons to call it out as yet another example in our state of abuse of power.
Is the Death Penalty Biblically Justifiable?
So, at best Newsom’s decision here is legally questionable. What about morally? I want to step out for you why Gavin Newsom’s ideology behind this decision is wrong, and why what he is doing is actually unjust, even though he argues it is “consistent” with our state’s values.
Capital punishment does not degrade the value of human life, it upholds it. It recognizes that some crimes – like murder – are so intrinsically heinous that they demand severe and permanent consequences. It asserts that the criminal has perpetrated such a dehumanizing crime that any other response would fall short of executing true justice on behalf of the dehumanized.
The death penalty was instituted by God, after the Flood but before the giving of the law. In Genesis 9:6, God mandates this: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for God made man in his own image.”[12] This mandate for capital punishment is rooted in the very value and worth of human life. Murder destroys an image-bearer, which makes it a direct affront to God Himself. Before the Flood, murder had become rampant, alongside all sorts of wickedness. But after the Flood, a new standard was raised as part of the recreated earth, which was that God would no longer tolerate murder.[13]
This standard is applied in the Old Testament over 20 times. Take the following examples:
- Exodus 21:12, “Whoever strikes a man so that he dies shall be put to death.”
- Numbers 15:35, “And the Lord said to Moses, ‘The man shall be put to death; all the congregation shall stone him with stones outside the camp.’”
- Deuteronomy 21:21, “And the Lord said to Moses, ‘The man shall be put to death; all the congregation shall stone him with stones outside the camp.’”[14]
When we get to the New Testament, we see that God’s standards have not changed. The same thread line of capital punishment for such serious crimes that devalue and dehumanize image bearers of God that was established under the old covenant remains in place even with the new covenant brought by Jesus, and the authority is specifically given to the government to carry it out. Romans 13, verses 2 through 4, are unmistakable in this:
“Therefore whoever resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer.”
God has clearly given authority to earthly rulers, namely our governments, to “bear the sword.” What does it mean to bear the sword? In its context, the sword was used to carry out executions. Meaning that God is prescribing here that it is the role of the governing authorities to be a terror to bad conduct, which includes carrying out the death penalty to enact the justice of God’s wrath.[15]
We see also in Acts 25 that Paul is on trial before Caesar, and he makes this claim in verse 11: “If then I am a wrongdoer and have committed anything for which I deserve to die, I do not seek to escape death. But if there is nothing to their charges against me, no one can give me up to them. I appeal to Caesar.” So, even Paul, as he stands before the governing authorities, recognizes that there are actions that can be committed that make a person deserving of death. How interesting that Paul does not take this opportunity, before Caesar himself, to call out the wickedness of a system that would execute certain criminals, or to preach about how under the new covenant this is no longer required, necessary, or just. Instead, he submits himself, saying he will accept the death sentence if he has committed any of the crimes deserving of it, but that he does NOT believe the charges are true and is therefore appealing to Caesar.[16]
So, the Bible is clear on this. God has mandated that because human life is SO valuable and SO precious, it is worth defending and avenging when it is taken or severely marred by man’s wicked actions. But how does this apply to Gavin Newsom’s arguments? And can these arguments still stand, even if you don’t believe in the Bible?
Responding to Objections
Let’s go back to the core objections that advocates for abolishing the death penalty, Gavin Newsom himself included, make, and respond to them.
First is the idea that the government should not take human life, even in response to horrific crimes. We asked the question earlier: Is the goal of convicting and sentencing a criminal simply to rehabilitate them? Now, based on the purpose of government and the authority given to it by God as just laid out, I would argue that is a fundamentally wrong view of government's role and responsibility.
The government has been given a specific responsibility to restrain evil, protect the innocent, and administer justice. Its role is not primarily to rehabilitate the criminal. That may be a good outcome of a prison sentence, and Christians should certainly desire the repentance and redemption of even the worst offenders. But rehabilitation is not the foundation of criminal justice.
When crimes like murder and child rape are committed, a profound offense has been made against the humanity and dignity of another person. That matters because human beings are not valuable simply because they are useful to society, or because they have the potential to contribute something good. They are valuable because they are made in the image of God. When someone deliberately takes another person's life, they have committed an offense against a person who bears that image. And Scripture gives the government authority to respond to that kind of evil with serious punishment.
So, when a government first and foremost asks, "What can we do to help the evildoer, the murderer, the criminal?" it loses sight of its primary responsibility to protect the innocent and carry out justice on their behalf. Of course we can care about what happens to the criminal; we should want them to repent, and should want them to come to know Christ! But those desires do not erase the government's responsibility to punish wrongdoing.
If we say that the government must never take a criminal's life, regardless of what that person has done, we are saying that capital punishment is inherently unjust. It is to reject a form of justice that God has explicitly entrusted to governing authorities. But Scripture does not treat it that way. It recognizes that there are crimes so grave that the death penalty is an appropriate exercise of the government's responsibility to administer justice.
The second argument was that our justice system is imperfect, and therefore we should not carry out the death penalty for fear of executing an innocent person. Let’s be clear from the start that no one believes innocent people should be executed for a crime they didn't commit. Obviously. And to respond to this, I don’t feel the need to entirely dismiss the possibility of wrongful convictions or pretend that our legal system is incapable of making mistakes. But I also think we need to examine the logic of this argument, because simply pointing out that a system is imperfect does not automatically mean we should abandon legal consequences.
Our legal system is not designed to convict people based on a single accusation or the opinion of one person. There are multiple stages of review and safeguards intended to protect the accused. There is the investigation, the collection and examination of evidence, the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, the right to legal representation, the opportunity to challenge evidence, the trial itself, and the appeals process. In capital cases, there are additional procedures and layers of review because the consequences are so serious.
Accusations of mistakes or failures need to be specific to where those processes are breaking down. For instance, is eyewitness testimony or forensic evidence being handled appropriately, is there police or prosecutorial misconduct, is there a pattern of inadequate defense representation – those are all specific problems that can be identified and addressed through reform. But simply saying, "The justice system is imperfect, therefore we should never execute anyone," doesn't address those underlying problems, and it is an easy scapegoat for policies that leaders don’t actually want to carry out.
Think about it this way. Do we stop arresting people because someone might be wrongly arrested? Do we stop imprisoning convicted criminals because someone might be wrongly imprisoned? Do we abandon the entire criminal justice system because it is possible for human beings to make mistakes? No! We establish standards of evidence, procedures, checks and balances, and avenues for appeal precisely because we recognize that mistakes are possible.
In America, we have a legal process that takes the possibility of error with the utmost seriousness and gives ample opportunity for appeal.
Lastly, there is the point that the death penalty doesn't necessarily produce justice because executions don't always provide meaningful closure or healing for victims' families. This fundamentally misunderstands what justice is. Justice is not determined by how someone feels about the outcome of a criminal case. Justice is based on an objective standard of right and wrong. It is about determining what was done, who is responsible, and what punishment is deserved for the crime that was committed.
The reality is that no criminal sentence, whether it is life in prison or the death penalty, can bring a victim back or undo the suffering they experienced. My mom is an attorney, and I remember her saying that she encountered the families of people who had suffered much. She would always say that emotional closure can never be the primary reason for going to court – because she had seen too many instances where even after the case was closed and done with, the families of victims were still left shattered. This of course will differ – after all, some people find great peace in seeing justice done! But that emotional experience is not what defines what justice is or what it requires.
The purpose of criminal sentencing is not to provide emotional closure. It is to administer justice for the crime that was committed. Which brings us back to the question of who gets to define justice. If justice is simply whatever produces the greatest amount of healing or emotional satisfaction, then we have made justice subjective. We have made it dependent on individual experiences and feelings, rather than on an objective moral standard.
But true justice is rooted in the character of God. It does not change based on how we feel about a particular case, how sympathetic we are toward the offender, or whether the punishment produces a satisfying outcome for everyone involved. God is just, and He has established standards of right and wrong that are not dependent on our emotions. Gavin Newsom does not have the authority to redefine those standards.
What Does Justice Require?
Gavin Newsom’s actions matter because this ideology affects real people, real crime, and real image bearers of God. This ultimately is not a political debate about the death penalty, but is more about how we, as a society, understand justice, the value of human life, and the responsibility of our government.
As conservatives and as Christians, we need to be thinking critically about these issues. We need to understand what God's Word says about it. So, I want to encourage you to do a few things.
First, solidify your stance on these issues, because they will continue to come up again and again in the news and in the culture. Read the passages of Scripture we've discussed today and study what the Bible actually says about justice and capital punishment. You need to be prepared to give an answer for why you support the policies you do.
Second, talk about this with your friends and your churches. These are important conversations to be having, and we shouldn't shy away from them just because they're difficult or uncomfortable! Our churches need to be beacons of clarity in an unclear world, standing firm on what is right, not on what is popular.
Lastly, NEVER take what our elected officials say at face value. Gavin Newsom’s open letter sounded really compassionate and empathetic. But when we dig deeper, when we ask questions and examine his arguments, then we expose the underlying beliefs that are informing his decisions. And those underlying beliefs are wrong.
Ultimately, the question we have to answer is this: What does justice require? And are we looking to God's Word to answer that question, or are we allowing our culture and our politicians to define it for us?
References:
[1] Folk, Zachary. “Gavin Newsom Commutes Death Sentences of All 548 People on California Death Row.” Forbes, November 5, 2026. https://www.forbes.com/sites/zacharyfolk/2026/11/05/gavin-newsom-commutes-death-sentences-of-all-548-people-on-california-death-row/.
[2] The Office of the Governor. “Governor Newsom’s Open Letter Regarding Commutation of All Death Sentences,” November 5, 2026. https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/2026-11-5-26-GGN-Open-Letter-FINAL.pdf.
[3] Folk, “Gavin Newsom Commutes Death Sentences of All 548 People on California Death Row.”
[4] The Office of the Governor, “Governor Newsom’s Open Letter Regarding Commutation of All Death Sentences.”
[5] Franklin-Best, Elizabeth, and Christopher Zoukis. “Presidential Pardon, Clemency & Commutation Explained,” July 3, 2026. https://whitecollar.net/pardons-clemency/.
[6] Justia U.S. Law. “California Constitution Article V - Executive Section 8.,” n.d. https://law.justia.com/constitution/california/article-v/section-8/.
[7] Ibid.
[8] Li, David, Erik Ortiz, and Tim Stelloh. “California Governor Commutes All Death Sentences,” November 6, 2026. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/california-gov-gavin-newsom-commutes-death-sentences-rcna607727.
[9] Lo, Kenny. “Clemency 101,” May 1, 2020. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/clemency-101/.
[10] Iovino, Nicholas. “Panel Recommends Repealing Death Penalty in California,” November 17, 2021. https://www.courthousenews.com/panel-recommends-repealing-death-penalty-in-california/.
[11] The Daily Journal. “Newsom’s Death Row Commutations Face Threatened Legal Challenge,” November 5, 2026. https://dailyjournal.com/articles/395907-newsom-s-death-row-commutations-face-threatened-legal-challenge.
[12] Genesis 9:6, ESV.
[13] GotQuestions.org. “Why Did God Mandate Capital Punishment for Murder (Genesis 9:6)?,” January 21, 2026. https://www.gotquestions.org/capital-punishment-murder.html.
[14] Voice of faith. “Should Christians Support Public Executions?,” October 14, 2026. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qZnPRh2S0Uk.
[15] Ibid.
[16] Ibid.